In a custody case, the court’s primary concern is the best interests of the child. This means that strong, well-documented evidence can make a significant difference in whether you are awarded joint or sole custody. Below, we outline the most persuasive types of evidence, how to present it effectively, and how your lawyer can help you build the strongest possible case.
Why Evidence Matters in Custody Cases
The court does not take parents’ statements at face value. Instead, judges rely on objective evidence to determine which parent can provide a stable, loving, and safe environment for the child. Your goal is to demonstrate that you are the best choice for custody and to challenge any false claims made by the other parent.
The most important factors the court considers include:
- The child’s well-being, safety, and stability.
- Each parent’s ability to provide for the child’s needs.
- The quality of each parent’s relationship with the child.
- Any risks to the child, such as violence, neglect, or instability.
Most Persuasive Types of Evidence in a Custody Case
-
Parenting Involvement Records
The court wants to see which parent has been the primary caregiver. You can provide:
- School records showing who attends parent-teacher meetings and helps with schoolwork.
- Medical records proving that you handle doctor’s appointments, vaccinations, and medical care.
- Activity schedules (sports, hobbies, daycare) showing who takes the child to activities.
- Daily routine logs documenting meals, bedtime, school drop-offs, and overall care.
Example: If you have always been the one taking your child to school, a letter from a teacher confirming this strengthens your case.
-
Witness Statements from Neutral Third Parties
Statements from professionals, teachers, doctors, and family friends carry a lot of weight. These witnesses can confirm:
- Your role as an active and caring parent.
- The child’s emotional well-being when in your care.
- Any concerns about the other parent’s behavior.
Who can provide a statement?
- Teachers – Can confirm which parent is most involved in the child’s education.
- Daycare providers – Can provide insight into the child’s routine and care.
- Doctors or therapists – Can assess the child’s emotional or medical needs.
- Family friends or relatives – Can provide testimony about your parenting abilities.
Example: A daycare worker confirming that you always pick up your child on time and provide proper care helps prove stability.
-
Proof of a Stable Home Environment
The court favors the parent who can offer a secure and consistent home. You can provide:
- Lease or mortgage documents proving stable housing.
- Photos or videos showing the child’s bedroom, study area, and living conditions.
- Utility bills proving financial responsibility.
- A schedule of daily routines to show structure.
Example: If the other parent moves frequently or lacks stable housing, your ability to provide a consistent home environment strengthens your case.
-
Communication Records with the Other Parent
If the other parent is uncooperative, aggressive, or negligent, text messages, emails, and call logs can serve as proof.
- Polite and cooperative messages show that you encourage a healthy co-parenting relationship.
- Aggressive or abusive messages from the other parent can demonstrate poor judgment or an inability to co-parent.
- Missed calls and ignored messages show a lack of involvement from the other parent.
Example: If the other parent frequently ignores messages about visitation schedules or school events, showing these records can highlight their lack of involvement.
-
Evidence of Domestic Violence or Neglect (if applicable)
If the other parent has a history of violence, neglect, or substance abuse, providing solid evidence is crucial. This can include:
- Police reports or restraining orders.
- Medical reports documenting injuries or signs of abuse.
- Therapist or counselor statements about the child’s fear or anxiety.
- Witness statements from neighbors or family members.
Example: If the other parent has a history of violence, a police report detailing past incidents can influence the judge’s decision.
-
Financial Stability and Ability to Provide for the Child
The court considers each parent’s ability to financially support the child. You can provide:
- Bank statements and payslips proving financial stability.
- Proof of child-related expenses, such as school fees and healthcare costs.
- Employment contracts showing job security.
Example: If you have a stable job and can financially support your child, while the other parent struggles with employment, this may favor your case.
-
Child’s Preference (If Old Enough)
In Sweden, the court considers the child’s own wishes depending on their age and maturity. Generally:
- At age 12 or older, the child’s preference is strongly considered.
- Between ages 7-11, the child’s wishes may influence the decision but are not decisive.
- Under 7, the court focuses entirely on the child’s best interests.
Example: If a 13-year-old strongly expresses a wish to live with you, their statement will carry weight in court.
How to Present Your Evidence in Court
-
Organize Your Documents Clearly
- Keep all school records, medical documents, and communication logs in a binder.
- Arrange evidence in a timeline format to show patterns of responsible parenting.
-
Avoid Emotional Arguments – Focus on Facts
- Judges rely on facts, not personal feelings.
- Keep your statements professional and avoid attacking the other parent.
-
Work with Your Lawyer
- Your custody lawyer will help you select the strongest pieces of evidence.
- They will challenge false claims made by the other parent.
- They will present a well-structured case to the judge.
Summary
The most persuasive evidence in a custody case includes:
- Parenting involvement records (school, medical, daycare).
- Witness statements from teachers, doctors, and family members.
- Proof of a stable home (housing documents, photos, financial records).
- Communication records showing responsible co-parenting.
- Evidence of neglect or violence (if applicable).
- Child’s preference (if old enough).
Your best strategy is to remain professional, provide factual evidence, and work closely with your lawyer to present the strongest case possible.
